I've weighed in with my last few posts in this series concerning life with Barack Obama as President. So, what if John McCain is our next President? How would that look to me? Let's start with some of the domestic issues.
John McCain has one mantra - tax cuts. So, in each of the debates when someone mentioned health care, education, the down-turn in the economy, McCain would sail along in platitudes until he landed back at "giving one hundred percent of Americans a tax cut". How do we fix health care? Tax cut. How about education? Give parents a tax cut. Our economy? You guessed it.
Here's the thing - I sort of agree with him.
Start with the easy one - the economy. How do we get consumers to consume? Give them more of their own money with which to work. It's proven time and again throughout history. How do we create more jobs and opportunities? Give businesses more of their profits with which to open jobs and pursue broader aims. Join, if you will, the jabs about Ronald Reagan's economic policies - but look at the results in the economy from Carter's policies to Reagan's. But you see, here is the important part: spending cuts. Tax cuts only work if the government reigns in spending.
This is where I hear John McCain speak strongly, but worry he doesn't carry a big enough stick.
Years ago a friend named Herman had a farm. On that farm he had the largest, and most violent rooster you could imagine. This rooster stood nearly the height of a sixth grader and weighed more. This thing had a mean disposition. I think he was carnivorous. The talons on this rooster were dangerous. He'd shred a man to bits just for walking in the pen. Whenever Herman had to go into the chicken pen he would literally grab a four foot lead pipe and take it in with him to keep the rooster away. Now, I tell you that to tell you this - Washington is full of a lot of fat and aggressive chickens. And I have a suspicion that they won't sit back and let John McCain cut money to all of their little pet projects so quietly. Look at President Bush. He worked hard to achieve tax cuts, but under his watch spending in Washington has looked a lot more like there was a Democrat in the White House than a Republican.
I have liked the ideas of working to cut costs in health care and for health insurance over a government take over, but again, I see... well... big violent chickens.
I like the idea of school choice and vouchers. Yet... big chickens.
Finally, one area I failed to mention while talking Barack Obama - Social Security. Do you remember Al Gore's "Lock-Box"? Wow. Memories. Nobody seems to be talking about Social Security much this time out. Interesting. I really liked the idea of privatizing Social Security until this latest market crash where a friend of mine, one who really knows the investment world, has pretty much lost his retirement in the last few weeks. Now here's the thing - I am not an expert on investments as I would assume most Americans are not experts. If experts like my friend lost his retirement in a couple of weeks, how gloriously could rank amateurs like me mess up? But then again, we see what government has done with its stewardship over our money. Hmm. Sounds like we need a new plan all together.
One overarching thought on all this: in principle, I don't expect the government to provide health care, education and a retirement for me. I expect that I work for a living to provide for my family's needs. I don't expect the government to educate me or my children for free. I expect that hard work will be rewarded with scholarships and grants, but that in the end my kids - like my wife and I - will need to work while in school, and perhaps even borrow some money (I hate the thought, but realize the necessity for many). And, I expect that my retirement will be the result of my earnings, savings and planning. At the moment, my plan is to work until I'm 101 years old. See! I have a plan. One that the government can't mess up and the markets can't eat away. I'll be the little old dude that greets you: "Welcome to Walmart!" Retirement! What a wonderful thing.
Still, I really do like the idea of government leaving me to control more of my money. I am a Republican through and through where the concept is concerned.
I like McCain in this area better than Obama, but fear, as I did with Obama, neither candidate will be able to actually accomplish what they are promising today... Obama fails because he simply cannot pay for his promises. McCain fails unless he carries a really big chicken-slapping stick. BBQ anyone?
Back next time to talk McCain and foreign policy.
Recent Comments