I've completed 12 chapters of William P. Young's fictional work, The Shack. I must say that I am rather enjoying it. This even after having taken a few tours around the blogosphere and reading many criticisms of the book and its theology. Here are some thoughts of mine through 12 chapters:
First, this is a work of FICTION. I really get bothered when people label something as heresy or spiritually deadly (both terms I've read on the internet spoken by believers whose names you would know) that is, in its nature, intended as entertainment not theological treatise.
Secondly, as people are screaming that the Trinity is being profaned and that Universalism is being implied, I ask: Does God the Father appearing to the main character in the book as a rotund black woman named Papa, or Jesus appearing as a rather unremarkable middle-eastern man, or the Holy Spirit as a halogram-like Asian woman cause you alarm? How about an assertion that while all roads don't lead to heaven, that Jesus willingly travels all roads to meet people?
Fiction. Right there on the back cover, the book's genre is listed as fiction. As fiction goes, this book has been engaging for me. I'm enjoying it.
Finally, reading this book IS stirring some of my theological thinking. Like I've always enjoyed Brian McLaren's (you know, that other great heretic across the blogosphere) fictional trilogy, Young has caused me to give much thought to God's perspective on human suffering, depravity and man's independence. I am of the mind that any work that causes you to consider God, and to revisit pat answers that have fallen short in your own experience, is very good.
I'll let you know if I'm still feeling that way when I'm done. But, so far, so good. I'd recommend the book.
Any thoughts from anyone out there who has read it?



Recent Comments